Showing posts with label corruption. Show all posts
Showing posts with label corruption. Show all posts

More destruction of Balikpapan Bay

1. Forest clearing in a protected coastal areas, ie. less than 200 metres from the sea.

The status of the area is High Conservation Value Forest. Its location is at the mouth of the River Berenga in the Tempadung estuary. The area being cleared with heavy machinery is broader than the former pond and a building has been erected.

The stones on the shores are an indication that there is the intention to build a pier. This area is very close to seagrass beds and coral reefs, the food sources for dugongs and dolphins. We are confident that confident that there is no licence for the work, or environmental analysis submitted given the high conservation value of the area.


2. Damage to the second mangrove estuary is happening in Puda where a company (yet to be confirmed PT Semen Gresik) has begun to build a wharf outside the Kariangau Industrial Area designated in the 2013-2032 Spatial Plan. This is an area of mangroves and construction is not in accordance with the Spatial Plan.


Map of the two locations


Much more info about the ongoing destruction of this environmentally important site can be found here

Gleanings Anew

Links to Indonesian Green news, often from international media, are published on this Facebook page, usually on a weekly basis. They will be posted here as part of the Gleanings series.

 - Apple to establish if tin from Bangka Island is used in iPhones as Friends of the Earth steps up pressure  to 'come clean' over use of child labour in Indonesia

- This is sad and as is this. Did the first lead to the second?

- Greenpeace and the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), a body that sets criteria for greener palm oil production, are caught up in a row over the origin of fires that cast a pall over Sumatra, Singapore, and Malaysia last month.

- Terusan village in West-Kalimantan (Indonesia) on the island of Borneo is completely surrounded by oil palm. The villagers grow rice and rubber on their ancestral lands. Recently, an oil palm company made Terusan an offer to convert their village land to an oil palm plantation. The people of Terusan have to make a choice about their future. They decided to map their ancestral lands as they attempt to take control of their future. Watch this video.

- Surprise, Surprise!
Corruption and mismanagement in Indonesia’s forest sector have cost the government billions of dollars in losses in recent years, including over $7 billion in losses from 2007-2011, Human Rights Watch said in a report released this week.

Update – Pulau Balang Bridge

I first wrote a month ago about the shenanigans in Balikpapan Bay which, thanks to land speculation and massive investment, largely from South Korea, will enrich local businessfolk and higher echelon government officials at the expense of the environment and local aspirations.

The following email from Stanislav Lhota is an update.

Dear All,

There is more news in the media (in bhs. Indonesia) about Pulau Balang Bridge, and all is bad ...

This article is basically a compilation of several similar media releases. On 12th March Governor Awang Faroek of East Kalimantan attended Agrinex Internasional Expo 2010 in Jakarta, where he was lobbying to find investors for Pulau Balang, besides other problematic projects, such as further extensions of palm oil plantations.

The other news concerns the ferry Somber, which has ceased operation due to the land ownership conflict. Balikpapan local government tried to buy the land but there was already an agreement. The Governor recently refused to intervene, stating that according to the tata ruang provinsi (Provincial Spatial Plan) transport will be directed to Pulau Balang, so there will be no further investment to improve the ferry transport.

Stanislav Lhota, M.Sc., Ph.D.
Dept. Zool., Univ. of South Bohemia & Usti nad Labem Zoo


Stan is planning to launch a website soon, possibly in blog format, which will give much more information, including environmental studies, than I can offer here.

If the Indonesian government is serious about being a world leader in environmental protection, a claim which cynics such as myself believe is a political smokescreen, then they should examine the background to the proposal to drive a major road through a national park and coastal mangroves and listen to the voices which elect them as well as the views of internationally eminent scientists such as Stan.

His publications are available here and you can also support him by email.

East Kalimantan - Balikpapan Bay bridge project

I haven't written about Kalimantan before although I do know where it is. I once sat in my seat on a Sempati plane as it sat on the tarmac at Balikpapan airport in transit to Jakarta.

This blog isn't called Jakartass for nothing, but I am concerned about maintaining Indonesia's biodiversity and I abhor political shenanigans and its embedded corruption so when I received the following email my interest was obviously aroused.

Hello J.

Would you be interested in reporting on Balikpapan Bay / Pulau Balang project, threatening the ecosystem there? This unfolding story has all characteristics of Indonesian development projects driven by greed.

My Czech colleague,
Stan Lhota (M.Sc., Ph.D. of the Department of Zoology at the University of Dept. Zool., Univ. of South Bohemia) is involved in an almost hopeless campaign to prevent the destruction of local biocorridors and mangrove ecosystems. He is originally a biologist rather than a campaigner, but in Indonesia, one has to assume both roles. I promised Stan a little help and I thought that informing/ involving the Indonesian expat community might be worthwhile although the interests in the project in provincial and central governments are powerful.

Stan is also involved in time-consuming fieldwork and if there is publicity and pressure from outside, he would certainly appreciate it.

This is
a statement from Mr. Miko, Biodiversity Director from DG Environment (Eur. Commission), former Czech Environment Minister who is interested in this cause.

A google search produced this page, well worth linking to, as it covers the issues in some depth.

Balikpapan Bay in East Kalimantan is home to an incredible variety of ecosystems: in the shallow bay waters endangered dugong feed on sea grasses and salt water crocodiles sleep; along the bay proboscis monkeys leap among mangroves thirty meters tall and Irrawaddy dolphins roam; beyond the mangroves lies the Sungai Wain Protection forest; here, the Sunda clouded leopard hunts, sun bears climb into the canopy searching for fruits and nuts, and a reintroduced population of orangutans makes their nests; but this wilderness, along with all of its myriad inhabitants, are threatened by a plan to build a bridge and road connecting the towns of Penajam and Balikpapan.

The bridge, known as Pulau Balang, would span the bay, splicing through Balang Island, cutting off the mangroves from the rainforest, and running the entire length of the western edge of the protected forest. While the direct impacts would be severe - deforestation for the road, splitting the mangrove from the rainforest, damage to the reef - researchers say that providing people easy access to the mangrove and forests will inevitably destroy them.


The page also lists some 14 endangered and vulnerable mammals, 5 endangered and vulnerable birds and 2 endangered amphibians


The proposed bridge is the dotted red line at the top, running below the Sungai Wain Protection Forest and then cutting through the dark green of the mangrove belt.

As ever, there are cheaper and less environmentally damaging alternatives, particularly the middle route on the map (Tanjung Batu - Gunung Seteleng). The lower bridge (Nipahnipah-Melaway) is perhaps not feasible as Balikpapan doesn't want heavy trucks going through the city.

So why, one may reasonably ask, haven't they been chosen?

There appears to be a conflict between local and provincial administrations

Recently, local governments, perceiving the many negative aspects of the project, have stepped away from supporting the Pulau Balang Bridge. Instead they have put their support behind the alternative road that would cause far less environmental harm and be a better option for their communities.

Yet the provincial and federal governments remain staunch supporters, capable of pushing the Pulau Balang Bridge through despite local concerns. Already, funds for the bridge and road have been secured by investors from South Korea.


There is also the matter of land speculation which has been ongoing since the early 1990s when the road was first planned.
..................................
Corruption in East Kalimantan
Kutai Kartanegara - Indonesia’s richest district
Indonesia Corruption Watch - Bank Kaltim paid Rp.18.59 billion in 'gratuities' to local leaders.
Corruption Eradication Commission (KPK) reports 1,254 corruption cases

Local Press Reports in Indonesian
Bupati (Regent) Andy Harahap speaks about Tanjung Batu - Gunung Seteleng bridge
Government website
Balikpapan - a brief article which explicitly states that the Tanjung Batu - Gunung Seteleng bridge would be the best alternative to the Pulau Balang Bridge.

I have written to both the Jakarta Post and the Jakarta Globe suggesting that they have better resources than I to investigate and report on this issue.

After all, if this case has stirred international concern, shouldn't it also matter to those of us in Indonesia?