Showing posts with label plantations. Show all posts
Showing posts with label plantations. Show all posts
Green Gleanings 1.8.13
Posted by
Jakartass
on
1.8.13
1. Palm oil company guards injure four villagers in Kalimantan clash
Four villagers were injured and several vehicles destroyed in a clash between local residents and palm oil company guards in Indonesian Borneo last week. The clash is the latest incident in a long-running conflict between Wilmar subsidiary PT Bumi Sawit Kencana and villagers in Kotawaringin Timur district, Central Kalimantan.
2. The Javan Rhino’s final stronghold
An article on the current state of a native Indonesia mammal in danger of extinction.
3. Through a new online fund-raising campaign on behalf of the Sumatran Orangutan Society featuring an animated orangutan called Armstrong, comedian Bill Bailey is asking animal lovers to help create new homes for the Sumatran orangutan by backing a rainforest restoration project that has just planted its 1,000,000th tree.
(Video)
4. Cute pictures of orphaned orangutans.
330 orphaned apes are cared for at the Orangutan Care Centre and Quarantine in Borneo, Indonesia. Human surrogate mothers look after the orphaned and rescued orangutans
Four villagers were injured and several vehicles destroyed in a clash between local residents and palm oil company guards in Indonesian Borneo last week. The clash is the latest incident in a long-running conflict between Wilmar subsidiary PT Bumi Sawit Kencana and villagers in Kotawaringin Timur district, Central Kalimantan.
2. The Javan Rhino’s final stronghold
An article on the current state of a native Indonesia mammal in danger of extinction.
3. Through a new online fund-raising campaign on behalf of the Sumatran Orangutan Society featuring an animated orangutan called Armstrong, comedian Bill Bailey is asking animal lovers to help create new homes for the Sumatran orangutan by backing a rainforest restoration project that has just planted its 1,000,000th tree.
(Video)
4. Cute pictures of orphaned orangutans.
330 orphaned apes are cared for at the Orangutan Care Centre and Quarantine in Borneo, Indonesia. Human surrogate mothers look after the orphaned and rescued orangutans
Gleanings Anew
Posted by
Jakartass
on
19.7.13
Links to Indonesian Green news, often from international media, are published on this Facebook page, usually on a weekly basis.
They will be posted here as part of the Gleanings series.
- Apple to establish if tin from Bangka Island is used in iPhones as Friends of the Earth steps up pressure to 'come clean' over use of child labour in Indonesia
- This is sad and as is this. Did the first lead to the second?
- Greenpeace and the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), a body that sets criteria for greener palm oil production, are caught up in a row over the origin of fires that cast a pall over Sumatra, Singapore, and Malaysia last month.
- Terusan village in West-Kalimantan (Indonesia) on the island of Borneo is completely surrounded by oil palm. The villagers grow rice and rubber on their ancestral lands. Recently, an oil palm company made Terusan an offer to convert their village land to an oil palm plantation. The people of Terusan have to make a choice about their future. They decided to map their ancestral lands as they attempt to take control of their future. Watch this video.
- Surprise, Surprise!
Corruption and mismanagement in Indonesia’s forest sector have cost the government billions of dollars in losses in recent years, including over $7 billion in losses from 2007-2011, Human Rights Watch said in a report released this week.
- Apple to establish if tin from Bangka Island is used in iPhones as Friends of the Earth steps up pressure to 'come clean' over use of child labour in Indonesia
- This is sad and as is this. Did the first lead to the second?
- Greenpeace and the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO), a body that sets criteria for greener palm oil production, are caught up in a row over the origin of fires that cast a pall over Sumatra, Singapore, and Malaysia last month.
- Terusan village in West-Kalimantan (Indonesia) on the island of Borneo is completely surrounded by oil palm. The villagers grow rice and rubber on their ancestral lands. Recently, an oil palm company made Terusan an offer to convert their village land to an oil palm plantation. The people of Terusan have to make a choice about their future. They decided to map their ancestral lands as they attempt to take control of their future. Watch this video.
- Surprise, Surprise!
Corruption and mismanagement in Indonesia’s forest sector have cost the government billions of dollars in losses in recent years, including over $7 billion in losses from 2007-2011, Human Rights Watch said in a report released this week.
Kencana Agro v Balikpapan Environment.
Posted by
Jakartass
on
13.3.13
Kencana Agri Ltd, which is listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange, say that they have "Environment-friendly Policies."
But do they?
This is their Jakarta HQ; any company or individual who can inflict such an eyesore on passers-by in an urban environment cannot be expected to have much concern for Mother Nature.
The Friends of Borneo - who started the petition "Wilmar Group and Kencana Agri of Indonesia: Back off Balikpapan Bay!" - have this to say:
Hi everyone!
Many thanks for having signed and shared this petition to protect Balikpapan Bay in Borneo.
We have won a partial victory! Wilmar Group has ceased all building activities and is in contact with local NGOs to work out plans to mitigate their impact on the environment.
However, Kencana Agri is still ignoring our calls to stop their activities and do a proper assessment of their impact.
Please support conservationist Stan Lhota who has issued a personal challenge to Kencana. Sign and share widely and let's save the orangutans, the proboscis monkeys and the Irrawady dolphins of Balikpapan Bay!
Yes, please do. You know it makes sense.
But do they?
This is their Jakarta HQ; any company or individual who can inflict such an eyesore on passers-by in an urban environment cannot be expected to have much concern for Mother Nature.
And this is from their corporate profile: In order to fully leverage and maximise the value chain of its plantation assets and logistics services, the Group, together with Louis Dreyfus Commodities, has built an integrated palm oil complex in Balikpapan comprising a deep water port, and a bulking terminal with storage capacity of up to 50,000 tonnes.
The Group will continue to expand this complex in the years ahead.
Hi everyone!
Many thanks for having signed and shared this petition to protect Balikpapan Bay in Borneo.
We have won a partial victory! Wilmar Group has ceased all building activities and is in contact with local NGOs to work out plans to mitigate their impact on the environment.
However, Kencana Agri is still ignoring our calls to stop their activities and do a proper assessment of their impact.
Please support conservationist Stan Lhota who has issued a personal challenge to Kencana. Sign and share widely and let's save the orangutans, the proboscis monkeys and the Irrawady dolphins of Balikpapan Bay!
Yes, please do. You know it makes sense.
Continued Environmental Damage in Balikpapan
Posted by
Jakartass
on
4.3.13
I have regularly posted an update of Stan Lhota's almost forlorn campaign to prevent the environmental destruction in East Kalimantan. (Read my February post for links to all the others.)
Stan has recently sent a couple of emails regarding this year's continued rapaciousness of non-local companies and their disregard of the damaging consequences of their actions on mangoves, the rivers and coral reefs.
1.
- PT Pelindo (port authority) have cleared mangroves and closed three tributaries.
- PT Bumi Andalas Bloom (WiImar Group) has been reported to the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) for illegal mangrove conversion and soil dumping.
- PT Agro Indomas (Goodhope Asia Holdings Ltd) is poisoning grass lands surrounding mangroves, thus poisoning the Palike River. In 2011, the company was awarded a Green PROPER Award for "commitment to environment and sustainable practices."
2.
The rarely found shallow water coral reefs of Balikpapan Bay, which are highly sensitive to silting due to increased erosion and sedimentation resulting from forest destruction along the coast, are also under serious risk.
- PT Dermaga Kencana Indonesia (DKI), a subsiduary of PT Kencana Agri Ltd (also listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange), plans to convert the coastal forest into a huge crude palm oil processing factory. DKI has built and now operate a palm oil bulking station which has already caused serious damage to several coral reefs!
Please help by signing and sharing this important petition! - Furthermore, illegal logging continues in Balikpapan and surrounding areas.
One further point: the Government of Balikpapan plans to relocate the Sun Bear Education Centre. The sun bear is Balikpapan's 'mascot', and the centre provides valued environmental education.
A petition has been launched asking the politicians to continue supporting the center and their sun bears.
Stan has recently sent a couple of emails regarding this year's continued rapaciousness of non-local companies and their disregard of the damaging consequences of their actions on mangoves, the rivers and coral reefs.
1.
- PT Pelindo (port authority) have cleared mangroves and closed three tributaries.
- PT Bumi Andalas Bloom (WiImar Group) has been reported to the Roundtable on Sustainable Palm Oil (RSPO) for illegal mangrove conversion and soil dumping.
- PT Agro Indomas (Goodhope Asia Holdings Ltd) is poisoning grass lands surrounding mangroves, thus poisoning the Palike River. In 2011, the company was awarded a Green PROPER Award for "commitment to environment and sustainable practices."
2.
The rarely found shallow water coral reefs of Balikpapan Bay, which are highly sensitive to silting due to increased erosion and sedimentation resulting from forest destruction along the coast, are also under serious risk.
- PT Dermaga Kencana Indonesia (DKI), a subsiduary of PT Kencana Agri Ltd (also listed on the Singapore Stock Exchange), plans to convert the coastal forest into a huge crude palm oil processing factory. DKI has built and now operate a palm oil bulking station which has already caused serious damage to several coral reefs!
Please help by signing and sharing this important petition! - Furthermore, illegal logging continues in Balikpapan and surrounding areas.
One further point: the Government of Balikpapan plans to relocate the Sun Bear Education Centre. The sun bear is Balikpapan's 'mascot', and the centre provides valued environmental education.
A petition has been launched asking the politicians to continue supporting the center and their sun bears.
Coal'd Comfort Redux
Posted by
Jakartass
on
29.3.12
I really didn't expect to return to a topic covered just a few days ago, but what I have learned since adds yet another dimension to my central thesis: coal mining at the behest of rapacious businesses, with their political cohorts cashing in, is a disaster for Indonesia.
Asia Calling is a regional current affairs programme produced by Indonesia's independent radio news agency KBR68H, and a partner of Tempo TV and Green Radio (89.2FM). It broadcasts in local languages to 10 countries across Asia, and its website is in Indonesian, English, Bangla, Khymer and Urdu.
Quinawaty Pasaribu, one of their reporters, recently visited Muarojambi village in Jambi Province, south east Sumatra, site of the last seat of the Sriwijaya kingdom.
The Muarojambi Buddhist temples were built in the 14th century and were only rediscovered, overgrown with vegetation, in 1974. Last September the President visited Muarojambi and promised to declare it a protected world heritage site: the temples are in line for UNESCO World Cultural Heritage listing.

Every historically-significant site in Indonesia is protected by the national 2010 Cultural Heritage Law which provides sentences of up to 15 years and fines as high as US$100,000 for anyone who destroys or sells parts of important sites. But the law is still not in force because President Yudhoyono has not signed regulations needed to put it into effect.

The site covers a massive 12 square kilometres which makes it the biggest in Southeast Asia, even larger than Java s Borobudur temple, or Angkor Wat in Cambodia, and much of the complex still awaits excavation, but is already under threat.
In 2010, the military built a road which encroached on the area, but after negotiations, the project was halted before too much damage was done.
But coal mining, the biggest business in the local area, now threatens to damage the temples beyond repair. More than 300 coal mining companies operate in the province and most of them stockpile coal around the nearby Muaro Jambi village before loading it onto boats on the Batanghari river near the village to send to India.
So far 11 major temples have been restored, just six percent of the whole site - dozens more temples are still buried under mounds of soil called menapos , which are all under threat from surrounding coal stockpiles.
Five mining companies, which have been operating since 2009 with permission from the local government, use the temple area to stockpile coal before exporting it overseas. Company security guards watch the area, and ask for entry permits from anyone who wants to enter the temple compound.

The threat from the coal mining industry is twofold: acid from the coal pollutes the river and seriously damages relics still buried underground and particles of coal dust also work their way into the temples' rock and get stuck inside.
But it's not just the temples that suffer. The temple complex land isn't only used by coal companies - thousands of people live there and also complain about the coal dust: The coal trucks pass by everyday here, hundreds of them. We inhale the dust, it makes us feel unwell.
Coal dust can cause pneumoconiosis and other respiratory diseases.
Burhanuddin Mahir, the head of the Muarojambi district government, claims the temples are protected: Let's say a coal mining company asks for a permit for an area of two hectares. If there's a menapo within the area, we will put a fence around it to protect the temple.
Quinawaty Pasaribu visited one of the menapos and there was no fence. The menapo was located inside the company's area, and was only 50 metres away from the nearest coal stockpile.
Local villagers say they ... don't want coal companies around the temple site ... if they can harm our cultural heritage. We have to protect the area. The government has to be firm about this.
Ah, but the government won't. After all, the coal industry is the "driver of the country's economy" this year.
Senior archaeologist Metta Dharmasaputra, the man behind the petition, says: " If we don't do anything about the temples' destruction, we can only say to our children and grandchildren in the future that there used to be a temple here. That it's gone now, it's just a fairy tale for our future generations.
"We're going to push people to save the Muarojambi site. This site is priceless. Getting people to sign the petition is just the beginning of our actions. "
You too can join the notable figures (including your correspondent): Sign the Petition
Asia Calling is a regional current affairs programme produced by Indonesia's independent radio news agency KBR68H, and a partner of Tempo TV and Green Radio (89.2FM). It broadcasts in local languages to 10 countries across Asia, and its website is in Indonesian, English, Bangla, Khymer and Urdu.
Quinawaty Pasaribu, one of their reporters, recently visited Muarojambi village in Jambi Province, south east Sumatra, site of the last seat of the Sriwijaya kingdom.
The Muarojambi Buddhist temples were built in the 14th century and were only rediscovered, overgrown with vegetation, in 1974. Last September the President visited Muarojambi and promised to declare it a protected world heritage site: the temples are in line for UNESCO World Cultural Heritage listing.
Every historically-significant site in Indonesia is protected by the national 2010 Cultural Heritage Law which provides sentences of up to 15 years and fines as high as US$100,000 for anyone who destroys or sells parts of important sites. But the law is still not in force because President Yudhoyono has not signed regulations needed to put it into effect.
The site covers a massive 12 square kilometres which makes it the biggest in Southeast Asia, even larger than Java s Borobudur temple, or Angkor Wat in Cambodia, and much of the complex still awaits excavation, but is already under threat.
In 2010, the military built a road which encroached on the area, but after negotiations, the project was halted before too much damage was done.
But coal mining, the biggest business in the local area, now threatens to damage the temples beyond repair. More than 300 coal mining companies operate in the province and most of them stockpile coal around the nearby Muaro Jambi village before loading it onto boats on the Batanghari river near the village to send to India.
So far 11 major temples have been restored, just six percent of the whole site - dozens more temples are still buried under mounds of soil called menapos , which are all under threat from surrounding coal stockpiles.
Five mining companies, which have been operating since 2009 with permission from the local government, use the temple area to stockpile coal before exporting it overseas. Company security guards watch the area, and ask for entry permits from anyone who wants to enter the temple compound.
But it's not just the temples that suffer. The temple complex land isn't only used by coal companies - thousands of people live there and also complain about the coal dust: The coal trucks pass by everyday here, hundreds of them. We inhale the dust, it makes us feel unwell.
Coal dust can cause pneumoconiosis and other respiratory diseases.
Burhanuddin Mahir, the head of the Muarojambi district government, claims the temples are protected: Let's say a coal mining company asks for a permit for an area of two hectares. If there's a menapo within the area, we will put a fence around it to protect the temple.
Quinawaty Pasaribu visited one of the menapos and there was no fence. The menapo was located inside the company's area, and was only 50 metres away from the nearest coal stockpile.
Local villagers say they ... don't want coal companies around the temple site ... if they can harm our cultural heritage. We have to protect the area. The government has to be firm about this.
Ah, but the government won't. After all, the coal industry is the "driver of the country's economy" this year.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Activists, academics and history buffs have started a petition to Save Muarajambi ancient temple site from industrial threats (which also include palm oil processing plants). So far, it has garned nearly 3000 signatures, including mine, from across Indonesia.Senior archaeologist Metta Dharmasaputra, the man behind the petition, says: " If we don't do anything about the temples' destruction, we can only say to our children and grandchildren in the future that there used to be a temple here. That it's gone now, it's just a fairy tale for our future generations.
"We're going to push people to save the Muarojambi site. This site is priceless. Getting people to sign the petition is just the beginning of our actions. "
You too can join the notable figures (including your correspondent): Sign the Petition
An International View of Indonesia
Posted by
Jakartass
on
25.3.12
"Being a captive animal in Indonesia is pure hell."
Watch the internet streamed multi-award winning documentary Green. This is about the poignant death of a female orang-utan which 'died of sorrow' because she had 'lost everything' - her forest habitat which has been ravaged by palm oil plantation conglomerates.This week the Daily Mail (UK) has a truly heart-wrenching article about her last days, an article which can only provoke tears intermingled with outrage.
Browse the Greenthefilm.com website for facts about the companies responsible for the rape of the forests, about complaisant companies whose products contain wood or palm oil from Indonesian plantations, and much more.Watch the film - and get angry!
Update – Pulau Balang Bridge
Posted by
Jakartass
on
16.3.10
I first wrote a month ago about the shenanigans in Balikpapan Bay which, thanks to land speculation and massive investment, largely from South Korea, will enrich local businessfolk and higher echelon government officials at the expense of the environment and local aspirations.
The following email from Stanislav Lhota is an update.
Dear All,
There is more news in the media (in bhs. Indonesia) about Pulau Balang Bridge, and all is bad ...
This article is basically a compilation of several similar media releases. On 12th March Governor Awang Faroek of East Kalimantan attended Agrinex Internasional Expo 2010 in Jakarta, where he was lobbying to find investors for Pulau Balang, besides other problematic projects, such as further extensions of palm oil plantations.
The other news concerns the ferry Somber, which has ceased operation due to the land ownership conflict. Balikpapan local government tried to buy the land but there was already an agreement. The Governor recently refused to intervene, stating that according to the tata ruang provinsi (Provincial Spatial Plan) transport will be directed to Pulau Balang, so there will be no further investment to improve the ferry transport.
Stanislav Lhota, M.Sc., Ph.D.
Dept. Zool., Univ. of South Bohemia & Usti nad Labem Zoo
Stan is planning to launch a website soon, possibly in blog format, which will give much more information, including environmental studies, than I can offer here.
If the Indonesian government is serious about being a world leader in environmental protection, a claim which cynics such as myself believe is a political smokescreen, then they should examine the background to the proposal to drive a major road through a national park and coastal mangroves and listen to the voices which elect them as well as the views of internationally eminent scientists such as Stan.
His publications are available here and you can also support him by email.
The following email from Stanislav Lhota is an update.
Dear All,
There is more news in the media (in bhs. Indonesia) about Pulau Balang Bridge, and all is bad ...
This article is basically a compilation of several similar media releases. On 12th March Governor Awang Faroek of East Kalimantan attended Agrinex Internasional Expo 2010 in Jakarta, where he was lobbying to find investors for Pulau Balang, besides other problematic projects, such as further extensions of palm oil plantations.
The other news concerns the ferry Somber, which has ceased operation due to the land ownership conflict. Balikpapan local government tried to buy the land but there was already an agreement. The Governor recently refused to intervene, stating that according to the tata ruang provinsi (Provincial Spatial Plan) transport will be directed to Pulau Balang, so there will be no further investment to improve the ferry transport.
Stanislav Lhota, M.Sc., Ph.D.
Dept. Zool., Univ. of South Bohemia & Usti nad Labem Zoo
Stan is planning to launch a website soon, possibly in blog format, which will give much more information, including environmental studies, than I can offer here.
If the Indonesian government is serious about being a world leader in environmental protection, a claim which cynics such as myself believe is a political smokescreen, then they should examine the background to the proposal to drive a major road through a national park and coastal mangroves and listen to the voices which elect them as well as the views of internationally eminent scientists such as Stan.
His publications are available here and you can also support him by email.
When the oil runs out and the plantations run dry …
Posted by
Jakartass
on
13.2.08
We live in a “Back to the Future” era where most of what powers our daily lives is in essence “Time Travel”. Exploiting the compressed remains from prehistory - the constant rain of plankton onto the ocean floor and the settlement of vegetation in anoxic swamps during the Carboniferous period - we are mining and extracting our distant past for acceleration in our present.
Our future, if we proceed as we do now, depends on the presumption that the past is not expendable.
The common view from the Energy Majors is that that this situation can be extended by opening new oil fields and by using unconventional oil (for example, oil extracted from tar sands). But these may cause environmental disasters of their own. Around half the new discoveries the oil companies expect over the next 25 years will take place in the Arctic or in the very deep sea (between 2000 and 4000 metres).
In either case, a major oil spill, in such slow and fragile ecosystems, would be catastrophic. Mining unconventional oil, such as the tar sands in Canada, produces far more carbon dioxide than drilling for ordinary petroleum. It also uses and pollutes great volumes of freshwater, and wrecks thousands of acres of pristine land.
The idea that we can simply replace this fossil legacy and the extraordinary power densities it gives us, with ambient energy is the stuff of science fiction. There is simply no substitute for cutting back.
Alternative energy supplies are always in discussion, the most common option within the world forum is the “Biodiesel Saviour”. Although proven technology, the use of biodiesel in the west will do nothing for South East Asia except make a few wallets very much fatter.
In promoting biodiesel, as the European Union, the British and US governments and thousands of environmental campaigners do, you might imagine that you are creating a market for old chip fat, or rapeseed oil, or oil from algae grown in desert ponds. In reality you are creating a market for the most destructive crop on earth.
Figures obtained last year in the UK by the activist group Road Block show that for the widening of the M1 alone the government will pay £3.6 billion, more than it is spending on its entire climate change programme. Instead of attempting to reduce demand, it is trying to alter supply. It is prepared to sacrifice the South East Asian rainforests in order to be seen to do something, and to allow western motorists to feel better about themselves.
Before oil palms -- which are in relation to the original vegetation, diminutive and bush-like - are planted, the vast canopies, containing a much greater store of carbon, must be felled and burned. With the incentive to plant more, the drier lands are already inundated with these straight lines of oil palm and the plantations are now moving into the swamp forests.
These swamplands grow on peat. When they’ve cut the trees, the planters need to drain the ground. As the peat dries it oxidises, releasing even more carbon dioxide than the trees. In terms of its impact on both the local and global environments, palm biodiesel is more destructive than crude oil from anywhere in the world.
Almost all the remaining Indonesian forests are at risk. Even the Tanjung Puting National Park in Kalimantan is being illegally ripped apart by oil planters. Throughout the nation animals are suffering!
The orang-utan is likely to become extinct in the wild, Sumatran rhinos, tigers, gibbons, tapirs, proboscis monkeys and thousands of other species could go the same way. Thousands of indigenous people have been evicted from their lands, and in some cases, it has been rumoured that Indonesians have been tortured when they tried to resist. The forest fires that every so often smother the region in smog are mostly started by palm growers. The entire region is being turned into a gigantic vegetable oil field.
Plantations are also "biological deserts". Because they are of one species they will by definition exclude the rich and diverse flora and fauna that lived on the site before the plantation was planted.
Plantations thus challenge the laws of nature.
More rationally a large concentration of one species will provide a food source for an insect predator that the same species scattered through a forest would not. This will allow the predator to escalate in numbers to an extent that it will devastate the plantation species and then after the plantation species is consumed, inflict severe collateral damage on any adjacent forest species because of high populations of starving insects.
The only control over the insect population would be of a chemical nature. This may prevent the scenario described above, but, will cause damage as the toxins such as pesticides, herbicides and fungicides, leach into the water system and poison the environment.
Thus, two environmental impacts are taking place one in the short term, before the plantation is established, and the second in the long term, an attrition over many hundreds of years that will leave Indonesia with nothing for the future.
As mentioned above, monocultures are more susceptible to pests and diseases: plantations risk poor health due to environmental stress from soil nutrient decline; climate change and an increase in UVB light; soil nutrients are being lost; forestry machinery causes sedimentation in waterways and subsequent damage to aquatic life; and perhaps, more importantly, many bird species and animal species are absent from plantations, and given the drive for Biodiesel may have nowhere to run, swing, slither or fly to for their future.
Re-thinking our planting, avoiding plantations and creating a new bio-diversity appears to be the only rational action!
If this approach were followed, Asia’s new forests would, besides preventing floods and landslides, soak up carbon dioxide. But they are less diverse than those still disappearing. Some are plantations of eucalyptus for papermaking, or other fast-growing species such as poplar, used for building materials. Others are fruit orchards. Nevertheless, even in plantation forests, if managed in an environmentally sound manner, nature subversively reinvades and populates them with a variety of other species.
In some places - Thailand is one example - there are projects to restore something pretty close to the original, diverse tropical forest. Nature does this by itself if left undisturbed. But conservationists are lending a helping hand by planting fast-growing “pioneer” tree species which provide a high canopy of foliage. This in turn speeds the regeneration of the original moist forest. If this were to take place, not only will Asia-Pacific’s forest area begin to regrow, but after centuries of shrinking there are even grounds for hope that some of its rich diversity can be re-created.
Within Indonesia, as you fly above almost all off Sumatra and Kalimantan today, the tranquillity that you seem to see below is in fact hundreds of thousands of square acres of straight lines comprising oil palm trees to satisfy biodiesel demand. The atmosphere above what used to be pristine rainforest is becoming more like the streets of Jakarta with these clouds of ash also drifting throughout South East Asia and polluting other nations into the bargain.
As with all peoples in the world, Indonesians need to make money, however, after many years of corruption at both major and minor levels, the mechanics of normal business routine and the wheels of commerce have been so badly tarnished that without some form of grease they will seize and nothing will happen at all.
This grease has prevented the formation of any kind of sustainable resource group as the brown envelopes are bigger carrots to businessmen and officials than the threatened snarl from public bodies trying to change both the mind set of the perpetrators and save a huge natural resource at the same time.
Two years ago, on my way to meetings within the heart of Riau Province, the landscape turned almost desert like. Yes there were oil palm trees, laid out like parade soldiers, however, there was an arid quality to the road and forest behind; dust clouds blew, smoke permeated everywhere and the few last arboreal giants stood naked, without leaves, merely waiting, towering above the non native palms to fall to their graves, because in truth they were already dead, and worse, unlikely to ever return.
Late last year, on the same road, I was shocked to discover how bad things actually were, scenes from Mordor in “Lord of the Rings” seemed tame compared to the devastation that continues throughout this area, and presumably, throughout the rest off the country.
If the Indonesians cannot see what is happening, or worse, are not aware that their children will only have memories of these once great jungles, I do indeed shed a tear for them, however, I cannot forgive them as what they are taking from the world is not theirs to take.
The only question worth asking is what we intend to do about it.
There might be a miracle cure. Photosynthetic energy, supercritical geothermal fluid drilling (such as the “hot rocks” project in Australia), cold fusion, hydrocatalytic hydrogen energy and various other hopeful monsters could each provide us with almost unlimited cheap energy. But we shouldn’t count on it. The technical, or even theoretical, barriers might prove insuperable. There are plenty of existing alternatives to oil, but none of them is cheap, and none offers a comparable return on investment to the “Energy Majors”.
Currently, geothermal energy provides Indonesia with its best option, which, if developed and a moratorium placed on new oil developments, would certainly be a move towards a greener and self sustainable future.
Oil production for fuel could be halted; the use of petrol and diesel for vehicles is a costly waste of oil’s true potential. Deplete the oil fields and you lose many off the materials we take for granted in our daily lives, although getting rid of Jakarta’s indigenous black plastic bag population would not be a bad thing. Sensible and ecologically sound exploitation at minimal levels would provide Indonesia with raw materials for many hundreds of years without the current need for “production for propulsion”.
The governments move towards LPG for cooking and transportation would at least allow the existing gas fields, which are sufficiently large to provide power for at least a century, to fuel the archipelago until other sustainable fuels are developed.
Weaning the country from the hydrocarbon tit is urgent, and may I add, not only within Indonesia. Unless we accept this the consequences do not bear thinking about!
When the oil runs out and the plantations run dry….. I’d say it was a better day all around for Indonesia!
.............................................
Dilligaf, Scottish, stuck in Jakarta, in an Industry he loathes (but rather enjoys at the same time) better known for his “other” contributions to Indonesian life on other forums (NSFW)
Our future, if we proceed as we do now, depends on the presumption that the past is not expendable.
The common view from the Energy Majors is that that this situation can be extended by opening new oil fields and by using unconventional oil (for example, oil extracted from tar sands). But these may cause environmental disasters of their own. Around half the new discoveries the oil companies expect over the next 25 years will take place in the Arctic or in the very deep sea (between 2000 and 4000 metres).
In either case, a major oil spill, in such slow and fragile ecosystems, would be catastrophic. Mining unconventional oil, such as the tar sands in Canada, produces far more carbon dioxide than drilling for ordinary petroleum. It also uses and pollutes great volumes of freshwater, and wrecks thousands of acres of pristine land.
The idea that we can simply replace this fossil legacy and the extraordinary power densities it gives us, with ambient energy is the stuff of science fiction. There is simply no substitute for cutting back.
Alternative energy supplies are always in discussion, the most common option within the world forum is the “Biodiesel Saviour”. Although proven technology, the use of biodiesel in the west will do nothing for South East Asia except make a few wallets very much fatter.
In promoting biodiesel, as the European Union, the British and US governments and thousands of environmental campaigners do, you might imagine that you are creating a market for old chip fat, or rapeseed oil, or oil from algae grown in desert ponds. In reality you are creating a market for the most destructive crop on earth.
Figures obtained last year in the UK by the activist group Road Block show that for the widening of the M1 alone the government will pay £3.6 billion, more than it is spending on its entire climate change programme. Instead of attempting to reduce demand, it is trying to alter supply. It is prepared to sacrifice the South East Asian rainforests in order to be seen to do something, and to allow western motorists to feel better about themselves.
Before oil palms -- which are in relation to the original vegetation, diminutive and bush-like - are planted, the vast canopies, containing a much greater store of carbon, must be felled and burned. With the incentive to plant more, the drier lands are already inundated with these straight lines of oil palm and the plantations are now moving into the swamp forests.
These swamplands grow on peat. When they’ve cut the trees, the planters need to drain the ground. As the peat dries it oxidises, releasing even more carbon dioxide than the trees. In terms of its impact on both the local and global environments, palm biodiesel is more destructive than crude oil from anywhere in the world.
Almost all the remaining Indonesian forests are at risk. Even the Tanjung Puting National Park in Kalimantan is being illegally ripped apart by oil planters. Throughout the nation animals are suffering!
The orang-utan is likely to become extinct in the wild, Sumatran rhinos, tigers, gibbons, tapirs, proboscis monkeys and thousands of other species could go the same way. Thousands of indigenous people have been evicted from their lands, and in some cases, it has been rumoured that Indonesians have been tortured when they tried to resist. The forest fires that every so often smother the region in smog are mostly started by palm growers. The entire region is being turned into a gigantic vegetable oil field.
Plantations are also "biological deserts". Because they are of one species they will by definition exclude the rich and diverse flora and fauna that lived on the site before the plantation was planted.
Plantations thus challenge the laws of nature.
More rationally a large concentration of one species will provide a food source for an insect predator that the same species scattered through a forest would not. This will allow the predator to escalate in numbers to an extent that it will devastate the plantation species and then after the plantation species is consumed, inflict severe collateral damage on any adjacent forest species because of high populations of starving insects.
The only control over the insect population would be of a chemical nature. This may prevent the scenario described above, but, will cause damage as the toxins such as pesticides, herbicides and fungicides, leach into the water system and poison the environment.
Thus, two environmental impacts are taking place one in the short term, before the plantation is established, and the second in the long term, an attrition over many hundreds of years that will leave Indonesia with nothing for the future.
As mentioned above, monocultures are more susceptible to pests and diseases: plantations risk poor health due to environmental stress from soil nutrient decline; climate change and an increase in UVB light; soil nutrients are being lost; forestry machinery causes sedimentation in waterways and subsequent damage to aquatic life; and perhaps, more importantly, many bird species and animal species are absent from plantations, and given the drive for Biodiesel may have nowhere to run, swing, slither or fly to for their future.
Re-thinking our planting, avoiding plantations and creating a new bio-diversity appears to be the only rational action!
If this approach were followed, Asia’s new forests would, besides preventing floods and landslides, soak up carbon dioxide. But they are less diverse than those still disappearing. Some are plantations of eucalyptus for papermaking, or other fast-growing species such as poplar, used for building materials. Others are fruit orchards. Nevertheless, even in plantation forests, if managed in an environmentally sound manner, nature subversively reinvades and populates them with a variety of other species.
In some places - Thailand is one example - there are projects to restore something pretty close to the original, diverse tropical forest. Nature does this by itself if left undisturbed. But conservationists are lending a helping hand by planting fast-growing “pioneer” tree species which provide a high canopy of foliage. This in turn speeds the regeneration of the original moist forest. If this were to take place, not only will Asia-Pacific’s forest area begin to regrow, but after centuries of shrinking there are even grounds for hope that some of its rich diversity can be re-created.
Within Indonesia, as you fly above almost all off Sumatra and Kalimantan today, the tranquillity that you seem to see below is in fact hundreds of thousands of square acres of straight lines comprising oil palm trees to satisfy biodiesel demand. The atmosphere above what used to be pristine rainforest is becoming more like the streets of Jakarta with these clouds of ash also drifting throughout South East Asia and polluting other nations into the bargain.
As with all peoples in the world, Indonesians need to make money, however, after many years of corruption at both major and minor levels, the mechanics of normal business routine and the wheels of commerce have been so badly tarnished that without some form of grease they will seize and nothing will happen at all.
This grease has prevented the formation of any kind of sustainable resource group as the brown envelopes are bigger carrots to businessmen and officials than the threatened snarl from public bodies trying to change both the mind set of the perpetrators and save a huge natural resource at the same time.
Two years ago, on my way to meetings within the heart of Riau Province, the landscape turned almost desert like. Yes there were oil palm trees, laid out like parade soldiers, however, there was an arid quality to the road and forest behind; dust clouds blew, smoke permeated everywhere and the few last arboreal giants stood naked, without leaves, merely waiting, towering above the non native palms to fall to their graves, because in truth they were already dead, and worse, unlikely to ever return.
Late last year, on the same road, I was shocked to discover how bad things actually were, scenes from Mordor in “Lord of the Rings” seemed tame compared to the devastation that continues throughout this area, and presumably, throughout the rest off the country.
If the Indonesians cannot see what is happening, or worse, are not aware that their children will only have memories of these once great jungles, I do indeed shed a tear for them, however, I cannot forgive them as what they are taking from the world is not theirs to take.
The only question worth asking is what we intend to do about it.
There might be a miracle cure. Photosynthetic energy, supercritical geothermal fluid drilling (such as the “hot rocks” project in Australia), cold fusion, hydrocatalytic hydrogen energy and various other hopeful monsters could each provide us with almost unlimited cheap energy. But we shouldn’t count on it. The technical, or even theoretical, barriers might prove insuperable. There are plenty of existing alternatives to oil, but none of them is cheap, and none offers a comparable return on investment to the “Energy Majors”.
Currently, geothermal energy provides Indonesia with its best option, which, if developed and a moratorium placed on new oil developments, would certainly be a move towards a greener and self sustainable future.
Oil production for fuel could be halted; the use of petrol and diesel for vehicles is a costly waste of oil’s true potential. Deplete the oil fields and you lose many off the materials we take for granted in our daily lives, although getting rid of Jakarta’s indigenous black plastic bag population would not be a bad thing. Sensible and ecologically sound exploitation at minimal levels would provide Indonesia with raw materials for many hundreds of years without the current need for “production for propulsion”.
The governments move towards LPG for cooking and transportation would at least allow the existing gas fields, which are sufficiently large to provide power for at least a century, to fuel the archipelago until other sustainable fuels are developed.
Weaning the country from the hydrocarbon tit is urgent, and may I add, not only within Indonesia. Unless we accept this the consequences do not bear thinking about!
When the oil runs out and the plantations run dry….. I’d say it was a better day all around for Indonesia!
.............................................
Dilligaf, Scottish, stuck in Jakarta, in an Industry he loathes (but rather enjoys at the same time) better known for his “other” contributions to Indonesian life on other forums (NSFW)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)