Showing posts with label nuclear power. Show all posts
Showing posts with label nuclear power. Show all posts

Govt wants to develop nuclear energy sources

Technology Minister Gusti Muhammad said on Tuesday that Indonesia needed to develop nuclear technology because fossil-based energy sources were depleting.

“If we are facing a fossil-based energy crisis, then we should try to develop nuclear technology.”

Gusti said that this plan needed to be followed up as soon as possible because developing nuclear-based technology would require a lot of investment and time.

“If we start developing now, then we can reap the results in 10 years,” he said.

Source: The Jakarta Post July 16 2013
................................................................................................
Given that the previous tenants in Jakartass Towers Redux laid some water outlet pipes which flowed inwards, one can expect that one result of a leak in an Indonesian power plant is that it would be botch repaired with plastic bags, masking tape and broom sticks, as happened at the San Onofre Nuclear Generating Station in December last year.

© Scripps Media, Inc. 2013

Indonesians “should think …

... twice before going nuclear!"

That's the strong message from Japanese experts Heizo Takenaka, a former internal affairs and communications minister and Yoichi Funabashi, who led an independent investigation team "the double whammy" of last year s tsunami and the Fukushima nuclear meltdown that followed.

Their arguments are familiar to readers of this blog and, indeed, anyone who's taken the slightest interest in the issue, so I'm not going to rehash all their arguments: Ring of Fire, radiation, costs of management, security, capital expenditure, maintenance, etcetera, etceter, etcet, etc, et, e, .....

Oh, and the storage of radioactive waste for the next couple of hundred thousand years.

In the UK, a report issued last month says that up to 1,000 sites could be contaminated with radioactive waste from old military bases and factories, though the best guess is that between 150 and 250 are.

In other words, in a mere 70 years or so of using radio-active materials in X-ray machines, radium painted on dials of military planes to make them visible in the dark, etcetera, etceter, etcet, etc, et, e, ..... the Ministry of Defence doesn't actually have a clear idea of where they've dumped the stuff.

This is the country which cannot stop folk littering or industries polluting rivers, so does anyone have faith that radioactive waste would be disposed of with no risk to residents and visitors?

Note
This week it is reported that wreckage from Japan's tsunami is now reaching the shores of the USA and Canada. Do you remember the reach of the 2004 Aceh tsunami?

Nuclear Power Industry Needs Experts ....

... who can google.

Earlier this year, in August, The Jakarta Post published an article of mine entitled 'New clear thinking before nuclear power.' Unfortunately, it would appear that no-one in BATAN (Indonesia's Nuclear Energy Agency) read it.

If they had, then Tri Murni Soedyartomo, a senior researcher at BATAN, would not, as reported in the Post on 12th November (Nuclear power needed before 2025, warn experts), have stated that "as fossil fuels could run out in 15 to 20 years’ time, Indonesia should build nuclear power plants."

It's too easy, glib even, to list the many failures of other experts to build adequate infrastructure or to prevent (and thereby cause) major catastrophes. The root cause is generally the failure to consider consequences. For example, the recent flood in Pondok Labu, East Jakarta, was caused by the narrowing of the River Krukut from six meters to two. In the immortal word of Homer Simpson, "Doh."

Another reason for these failures is the lack of reasoning, of not following President SBY's dictum at the beginning of 2008 to "Think Outside The Box". Mind you, some have suggested to me that the greatest failing is in actually think inside the box.

With minimal googling, Ibu Murni could have discovered that it is an illusion to build new nuclear power plants in the short time she suggests. The time frame needed for formalities, planning and building of a new nuclear power generation plant in the western democracies is in the range of 20 to 30 years. In other words, with the best will in the world, it would be impossible to have a nuclear power plant online before 2031, six years after her supposed deadline.

That Indonesia would need ten such power plants to meet the shortfall in generated electricity indicates a much longer time frame, and therein lies another major problem. The current estimate of the reserves of the fuel needed for nuclear power plants, uranium, are only sufficient for forty years at the current rate of 'consumption. By the time that Indonesia's hypothetical plants come onstream, uranium will have gone the way of fossil fuels.

So, what are the alternatives?Markus Wauran, a researcher from the Indonesia Nuclear Society (HIMNI), was in agreement with Ibu Murni, saying that Indonesia was prone to an energy crisis due to the country’s declining fossil fuel reserves. There are few who would disagree with his statement that: “We should consider building power plants to utilize other energy sources."

However, he then suggested that alternatives such as geothermal energy and wind power needed to be built "on a massive scale” and that "solar power plants could prove to be costly as one megawatt of energy would require building one hectare of solar cells."

This is bullshit.

Because of declining equipment costs, the spot price of solar panels has dropped about 40 percent this year, and it is suggested that the price could drop still further to match that of coal-fired plants within ten years. This is a great incentive to not go down the nuclear path, vide India which expects to have installed a solar power capacity of 20,000 megawatts, equivalent to about 18 nuclear reactors, by 2022.

But why should "massive" power plants be built in the first place? These are intended to supply large populations and if the intent is to supply the estimated 30% of Indonesia's population not connected to the national grid, mostly because they live in isolated villages, then an expansion of the transmission line network would be needed. Estimates, which require a knowledge of physics I admit is beyond me, indicate that about 10% is lost over long distances.

All power plants should therefore be sited to serve local needs. To serve the needs of the nigh on 13 million inhabitants and commuters of Jakarta, an ever-growing number, this could mean that a power plant should be built in Jakarta's 'Golden Triangle', rather than, say, Bangka in Sumatra. As suggested by former President Habibie, and former Minister of Research and Technology, at a conference on renewable energy in February 2010, Bali and Lombok could be served by the utilization of the kinetic force of ocean currents in the Lombok Strait,

Away from such major population centers, however, there is surely no need to build power plants with the capacity to generate many megawatts of electricity when kilowatts are sufficient to power lights, TVs and to charge hand phones.

A number of small scale projects have been successfully developed throughout Indonesia.

  • Nusantara Development Initiatives (NDI) sponsors Project Light which aims to “bring light to lives” by introducing environmentally-friendly solar-powered lamps to villages with scarce electricity in Indonesia.
  • Hitachi High-Tech of Japan has completed testing of a combined solar power generation and water purification system in the village of Bekkae in South Sulawesi.

  • PALAPA is a program initiated by students from the Bandung Institute of Technology which aims to build energy independent villages that take advantage of the renewable energy source, primarily solar and hydro, available locally, and turn it into economic activities to help support the welfare of the villages.
There are undoubtedly many more projects to emulate, some sponsored by state electricity company, PLN, who have agreed to increase fees paid for power produced from biomass, biogas and city waste. This is good as they obviously don't have much of a clue about nuclear power.

It has been widely reported that State Enterprises Minister Dahlan Iskan, a former PLN managing director, has approved the construction of a 200-kilowatt nuclear plant starting this year. I figure that would be enough for our fairly short street for a day.

Whatever, we can also put off the need for capital intensive power plants by reducing our collective demand for electricity. In pre-reformasi times we were regularly extolled to Hemat Energi, Hemat Biaya - Save Energy, Save Costs.

If we can remember that mantra, and obey it, then we can hopefully forget the pipedreams of BATAN and PLN.

.....................................................................

Footnote

With French Greenpeace activists today breaching the security of nuclear plants this week, continued worry about the long-term effects of the tsunami-hit Fukushima plant in Japan, which until yesterday was leaking radioactive water into the Pacific and has yet to decide how to safely dispose of 30 million tons of radioactive soil, it's surely nonsensical for Indonesia, which can't keep bridges standing for more than ten years, to even contemplate keeping a nuclear power plant safe for long.


New Clear Thinking Power Before Nuclear Power

Indonesian studies scholars rarely attempt to shed light on how technology is particularly suited to serve the political interests of those who seek to control other groups or to establish a political order maintaining the status quo.
Sulfikar Amir: The State and the Reactor: Nuclear Politics in Post-Suharto Indonesia (2010)


Back in March, the spokesman of the Nuclear Energy Agency (BATAN) Ferhat Aziz stated that Batan has sufficient human resources to support the development of a nuclear power plant.




That leads to the question of how he defines 'human resources' because he then went on to say that "the project would not go ahead anytime soon because there were so many factors to take into consideation - such as the environment, climate, geology and geography and including finding a location not prone to tsunamis, volcanic eruptions or earthquakes."

Presumably there are no environmentalists, climatologists, geologists or map readers on the BATAN staff, thus putting the lie to his initial statement. There's also the small matter of not having enough plumbers. In researching his paper Sulfikar Amir used the toilets a few times at the BATAN head office in Jakarta, and observed that "the toilet was not as clean as those found in five-star hotels, and the sink was leaking."

The same could be said about my house, but I'm not planning to develop a nuclear power plant any time soon. There also can't be anyone with sufficient knowledge to maintain a website either because the  BATAN Radioactive Waste Technology Center webpage has been "down for maintenance" for at least four years.

Most of us presume that the official spokesperson of whatever organisation or person is authorised to inform the public, via the media, of the 'official line'. However, BATAN is far from transparent in its dealings.

On Tuesday 4th July, BATAN head Hudi Hastowo told reporters that Bangka Belitung was considered to be the most suitable site for a nuclear power plant, due to geological and geographical reasons - there's a granite sub-strata and the sea is relatively shallow so tsunamis are unlikely.

He then went on to say, as quoted in the Post, that Batan finished feasibility and site studies in Bangka Belitung in January and had planned to announce the results of the bidding to build the power plant in March. However, the Fukushima Daiichi nuclear disaster on March 11 created political and social situations that were inconvenient for announcing the results.

Thanks for the honesty, Pak Hudi, but authorising Ferhat Aziz to cloud the issue is a strong indication that your organisation is not to be trusted.

In his very readable paper, Pak Amir analyses how in post-colonial Indonesia the "interplay between politics and technology continued to influence Indonesian politics in the postcolonial era, where the role of technology became more pivotal as it contributed to the construction of ideology and nation-building processes."

B.J. Habibie Ph.D, who holds some 46 patents, is the obvious example of this. In 1974, having returned from his studies and work as an aeronautical engineer in Germany, he was made CEO of state-owned enterprise PT. Industri Pesawat Terbang Nurtanio (IPTN) in Bandung, named after an early Indonesian aviation pioneer.

In 1985 the 'N' was replaced with 'Nusantara' (Archipelago). Following the Asian economic crisis (krismon), in 2000 the company was restructured and renamed PT. Dirgantara Indonesia (Indonesian Aerospace Inc.)

In that year, B.J. Habibie was already an ex-President.

And just this month (July 2011), the government has said that it will inject Rp.2 trillion ($234 million) to Indonesian Aerospace to keep the debt-ridden firm afloat. This is in addition to its unpaid debt to the government of.1.1 trillion ($129 million).

But that's peanuts compared to the cost of building and maintaining a nuclear power plant, cost that must ultimately be borne by the state. The upfront capital investment required to build a 1400 MW plant in the USA is currently about $2 billion.

Quoted in the Post in early July, Bangka Belitung Governor Eko Maulana Ali said: "To build a 1-gigawatt (=1000MW) power plant, we need approximately 35 trillion rupiah (US$4 billion). As we are planning to build two power plants in the Muntok and Permis areas, 70 trillion rupiah is needed. The government is not concerned on the cost as many foreign investors are ready to support the project."

But in his press conference, Hudi Hastowo said that to supply 2 percent of the electricity demand Indonesia would need to construct four nuclear power plants with a capacity of 4,000 MW. Where would the other two be sited? Presumably Governor Eko is talking up a higher budget because of expected inflation and the usual over-run costs.

As for the foreign investors, among others, interest has been shown in the past few years by Korea's state-run, Hydro & Nuclear Power Co, Mitsubishi of Japan and Russia's electricity company Raoues.

The latter is interesting in that in 2006 Gorontalo Governor Fadel Muhamad - now the Minister of Maritime Affairs and Fisheries - had a wizard scheme to overcome Indonesia's energy crisis. He announced a deal with them to build Indonesia's first nuclear power plant on a ship floating off the shore of Gorontalo.

There are a number of other factors which no-one seems keen to talk about.

Apart from the need to recruit highly qualified and trained qualified staff, presumably from abroad as there are none in Indonesia, there is the small matter of the fuel, uranium.

There is doubt about the amount of reserves In Indonesia. It is estimated that there are 29,000 tons in West Kalimantan and 24,000 tons in Bangka Belitung. Each 1000MW power plant would require 200 tons per annum, which would mean that if, and it's a big IF, all the reserves were extracted, purified and transported to the four power plants, they would be able to operate for c.36 years, some ten years shorter than the planned 'life expectancy' of most nuclear plants. For further plants to come onstream, uranium would have to be imported, yet it is estimated that world reserves would only last for 44 years for the c.436 plants currently in operation worldwide.

So, the outlook for the nuclear industry is limited. And then must be added the costs of decommissioning as well as the yet to be resolved problem of the radioactive waste which will remain lethal for 100,000 years, some 80,000 years longer than homo sapiens have been around. And all because of the 'need' to preserve a short-term political status quo? Or brown envelopes?

....................................................................  
Originally published in the Jakarta Post 8th August 2011 I'm posting this now because yet another article has appeared in the Post in which more BADAN "experts" suggest that nuclear plants are needed NOW. I will be submitting another riposte to the Post.

Is it so easy to fool Indonesians?

There was a very short article in yesterday's Post, one I can't find online. Yet it's probably one of the most serious attempts to hoodwink the Indonesian public I've ever come across.

Indonesia and France on Thursday signed an agreement on cooperation in nuclear power plant research.

The agreement came amid a long-standing controversy over government plans to build a nuclear power plant in the central Java town of Jepara to ease the electricity deficit plaguing the country.

After signing the memorandum of understanding with French Ambassador Catherine Boivineau, State Minister for Research and Technology Kusmayanto Kadiman said, "There have been no reports of problems with Frances nuclear power plant technology, which is extraordinary."

What is truly extraordinary is that the minister hasn't done any research using the technology available to the likes of you and me - a search engine.

This calendar page compiled by Greenpeace gives some examples of the everyday nuclear incidents that have occurred all over the world. It demonstrates how technological failures coupled with human error risk public health and the environment on an almost daily basis.

The first accident listed only dates from 1954, thus ignoring the first A-bomb tests, and goes up to 1993. However, it still lists the following twenty, count 'em, 'accidents' and equipment failures in French nuclear power plants.

1967 November 7: Release of radioactivity at Grenoble nuclear power plant
1968 October 2: Leakage at La Hague reprocessing plant
1969 October 17: Fuel elements melt at St Laurent des Eaux nuclear power plant
1980 September 22: Pump failure causes release of radioactive water at La Hague reprocessing plant
1981 January 6: Accident at La Hague reprocessing plant
1983 October 1: Technical failure and human error cause accident at Blayas nuclear power plant
1986 August 19: Flooding at the Cattenom nuclear power plant
1988 April 28: Release of 5000 Curies of tritium gas from the Bruyere le Chatel military nuclear complex
1988 November 23: Two control rods jammed at Blayais nuclear power plant
1989 April 1: Control rod failure at Gravelines nuclear power plant
1990 January 28: Pump failure during a shut-down at Gravelines nuclear power plant
1990 May 26: During refuelling, five cubic meters of radioactive water spilled at the Fessenheim nuclear power plant
1990 September 16: Superphenix Fast Breeder Reactor is closed down due to technical failures
1990 November 4: 2 workers irradiated during refuelling at Blayais nuclear power plant
1991 June1: Failure of core cooling system at Belleville nuclear power plant
1992 July 22: Two workers contaminated at Dampierre nuclear power plant
1992 July 22: Temperature rise in storage pool at Gravelines nuclear power plant
1992 August 28: Fire in electro-generator at St.Alban nuclear power plant
1993 January 20: Technical failure at Paluel causes subcooling accident
1993 October 22: Instrumentation and Control failure at Saint Alban nuclear power plant

French President Nicolas Sarkozy is engaged in nuclear diplomacy. Sarkozy has been leveraging France’s leading civilian nuclear technology to gain diplomatic, commercial and military advantages with countries in the Middle East, as well parts of Africa and Asia.

Since taking office last May, Sarkozy has signed deals worth billions of dollars to build nuclear power reactors or offer technical advice to a number of Arab states including Algeria, Libya, Morocco, Qatar, the United Arab Emirates, and now Indonesia.

The deal with Libya has really upset the island state of Malta because they feel threatened by their proximity to a potential nuclear accident.

You see, one took place between Monday 7 and Tuesday 8 July at the Tricastin plant in Bollene, 40km from Avignon, in the heart of the Côte du Rhone wine-producing region. After a plant malfunction, some 30,000 litres of a solution containing 12% enriched uranium overflowed from a reservoir into the nearby Gaffiere and Lauzon rivers.

A spokesperson for France’s nuclear safety agency, Evangelia Petit, admitted that the concentration of uranium in the two rivers was 1,000 times higher than normal after the spill. Enriched uranium is highly carcinogenic and a potential source of radiation poisoning, but Petit downplayed the consequences of last week’s leak, claiming that the risk posed to humans was “slight”.

Nonetheless, inhabitants of nearby towns and villages have been banned from fishing, swimming, drawing well water or using water from the polluted rivers for irrigation purposes

A "slight risk to humans"? Is that a similar cover up to that of the recent release of plutonium into the sewage system of Boulder, Colorado, which was “below the legal limits”?

If Minister Kusmayanto Kadiman really did not know about the most recent accident in France, then he should be fired for gross incompetence.

And if he did know .... ?

Another Anti-Nuclear Rant?

Although news about Indonesia's proposed nuclear power plant has been scant recently, it is worth reminding ourselves - and the élite of the business and political worlds - that no country has yet achieved energy self-sufficiency from nuclear power and, most importantly, no country has solved the problem of the disposal of the radio-active waste generated.

I have burdened readers of my anti-nuclear stance 33 times in the life of Jakartass - type 'anti-nuclear' or 'nuclear power' in the SEARCH box in the right column for the multifarious reasons.

This post is not a rant because there's enough recent evidence around from the pioneers of nuclear power - the UK - to demonstrate that for Indonesia to follow the nuclear route would be madness. What I am referring to is a catalogue of disasters in the British nuclear industry rather than the inadequacies of the Indonesian government, local authorities and private companies in maintaining the country's roads.

Don't take my words for it - please click on the links.

Nuclear Power for Dummies
Is nuclear power the answer to the energy crisis? Ian Sample explains how it works - and how we get the awful side-effects of bombs and waste.

The many problems of Sellafield

Britain's nuclear complex at Sellafield is Europe's biggest single industrial site and home to what was meant to be a huge fuel reprocessing system that would produce power while reducing the legacy of radioactive waste. It was built amid enthusiasm that atomic power would be "too cheap to meter" and yet, 52 years on, its catalogue of failures has left it with one of the world's largest stockpiles of plutonium and a bill to the taxpayer of about £3bn a year, a new report says.

Radioactive waste storage at Sellafield

Sellafield houses two state-owned reprocessing works and a plant for making mixed uranium and plutonium fuel called Mox. None of these facilities, which cost hundreds of millions of pounds, work as they were meant to do. Their problems are rebounding on the part-privatised British Energy (BE), which is wholly dependent on Sellafield to reprocess and store spent fuel from its 14 advanced gas-cooled reactors.

The difficulties have also hit the Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA), which the government set up in 2004 to preside over the £72bn clean-up of all British atomic sites and which was meant to be partly funded by income from reprocessing spent fuel.

Costs of Decommissioning 1
The Nuclear Decommissioning Authority (NDA), which is nursing a £300m budget overrun for 2006-07 alone, is attempting to raise cash to help pay for a £72bn clean-up bill. It plans to do this by selling off, to the private sector, everything from stockpiled uranium to atomic fuel manufacturing plants and land at 18 sites where they hope new nuclear plants will be built.

Contamination
Two kilometres of beach outside one of Britain's biggest nuclear plants, Dounreay, have been closed since 1983, and fishing banned, when it was found old fuel rod fragments were being accidentally pumped into the sea. The cause was traced and corrected but particles - including plutonium specks, each capable of killing a person if swallowed - are still being washed on to this bleakly beautiful stretch of sand and cliff on mainland Britain's northern edge.


Robot submarines fitted with a Geiger counter are to be used to sweep the seabed in one of the most delicate clean-up operations ever in this country. Each submersible will crisscross the sea floor to pinpoint every deadly speck close to Dounreay before lifting each particle and returning it to land for safe storage.

Costs of Decommissioning 2
Although the UK Atomic Energy Authority (UKAEA) kept no precise accounts for building and running Dounreay on Scotland's north coast, it is known to have cost several billion pounds. Now a further £2.5 billion will be spent returning the site to its pre-nuclear condition, leaving only a vault, covered with grass, to hold low-level nuclear waste while high-level waste will probably be shipped to a central UK nuclear store yet to be approved.

Waste Disposal
Scientists know that eventually they need to find a way of storing nuclear waste safely for thousands of years. Some countries, such as America and Finland, plan to store nuclear waste in deep underground bunkers. For this to be safe, scientists have to be sure the material could never leak out and contaminate water supplies or rise up to the surface. Other plans for disposing of nuclear waste have included dumping it at sea and blasting it into space

Apparently Britain already has more than 100,000 tonnes of radioactive waste that needs to be stored. No country has yet decided on a definitive method, or place, for the disposal of its radioactive waste.

Sellafield which was built to reprocess nuclear fuel, thus reducing the waste, has been a monumental failure. This February Malcolm Wicks, the energy minister, admitted in parliament that the plant had only produced 2.6 tonnes of reprocessed fuel in 2007 and a total of 5.2 tonnes since it opened in 2001, despite promises it would produce 120 tonnes a year.


On-Site Safety
Work on Britain's Trident nuclear warhead programme was suspended for much of the last year due to wide-ranging safety fears, it has been disclosed. Following suspension of work at the Atomic Weapons Establishment (AWE) Burghfield in Berkshire last July, when flooding increased the risk of fire at the plant, concerns about on-site safety became so acute that a decision was taken in the autumn to stop all live nuclear work on missile warheads.

AWE claims to be a 'centre of technological excellence, with some of the most advanced research, design and production facilities in the world'.

Alternatives
A study, commissioned by the UK's Department for Business, Enterprise and Regulatory Reform, has shown that British buildings equipped with solar panels, mini wind turbines and other renewable energy sources could generate as much electricity a year as five nuclear power stations. Furthermore, the report has shown that a large-scale switch to micro renewable energy units could save 30m tonnes of CO2 - the equivalent of nearly 5% of all the emissions produced in generating UK electricity.

Tom Tuohy R.I.P.
An unsung hero, his bravery averted a possible British nuclear catastrophe.